Frozen Time at London’s National Gallery Taking shelter with a warm cup of tea at the National Cafe on a rainy London day is never a bad idea—coupled with getting lost among the plethora of luring graphics at the National Gallery. While some works seem to summon more viewers than others, there’s a particular painting I keep finding myself at an interface with, while still trying to fathom its meaning. That is none other than the gallery’s most curious, enigmatic, and perhaps even disturbing painting in room 8—or maybe even in the entire National Gallery itself. Constantly drawn towards the same canvas, I read it as a piece of visual poetry where every figure stands for something, and the observer is at the mercy of Venus’s eyes, which continue to tease the contemplator conspicuously about the painting’s hidden meanings. Agnolo Bronzino’s ‘Allegory with Venus, Cupid, Folly and Time’ lacks the typical Renaissance painting’s harmony, structure, and focus--leaving the observer with many things to view, with eyes and minds in a state of perpetual inconclusive wandering. As Venus and Cupid lay there, blatantly enamoured in an almost-kiss--lifelike, not a brushstroke in sight--one cannot help but wonder: ‘what does time have to do with this?’, ‘who’s who?’, or simply, ‘What’s going on here?’ According to Einstein, ‘For us who believe physicists, the distinction between past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.’ This idea comes into play in Bronzino’s allegory, where all sense of time is glaciated around and within the figures of Venus and Cupid, and Time is embodied in an allegory incarcerated within the physical boundaries of the painting’s ontic reality. Beyond all this, it is interesting, and maybe even a bit amusing to contemplate this Renaissance masterpiece in terms of some modern philosophical theories on time here and there. While savouring the different hues of colour, we tend to find these theories in a medium where space and time are not absolute, but rather, are represented in a two-dimensional continuum. But the painting’s enigma remains unsolvable…there still is a lack of consensus, a large amount of dissention, and varying degrees of certainty on the identification of the painting’s figures. A spooky, hollow, eyeless, and perhaps brainless figure who’s believed to be Oblivion looms above the couple in the upper left corner of the painting, while below her stoops an anguished figure interpreted as Jealousy (and later on, seen by some scholars as Syphilis). Towards the lower right is a twisted, anatomically distorted ‘lady’ holding honeycomb (pleasure) in one hand and her stinging tail in the other--her twisted posture and serpent tail trick the reader into seeing that her right hand is her left, making her known as the embodiment of Deception. By her side, Folly carries roses toward the couple, while stepping on some thorns himself. However, the major focal figure besides Venus and Cupid is Chronus, or Father Time, the white-bearded figure at the upper right of the painting, with his hour glass on the back of his shoulders and his arms about to move a silk blue drape either away from or over Venus and Cupid. One thing that is for sure in the painting is that Time is present, but he is not perceived or experienced by neither of the two ‘lovers’. Many art historians and other interpreters have seen Time’s gesture with the cloth as an attempt at unveiling the couple, but it can also be seen from an opposite vantage point: an attempt to conceal, rather than reveal. I see Chronus’s gesture in that light, by taking into consideration a modern theory on time--namely that of Sartre. Moving forward a few centuries and having Sartre in mind, the allegory suddenly appears to make a different type of sense to me--albeit one that may be a bit far from the painter’s intentions--as some pieces of this intellectual puzzle begin to fall into place. Both Venus and Cupid appear to be completely unaware of Chronus and the other figures surrounding them (Folly, Deception, Oblivion, and Jealousy/Syphilis) in a complete detachment from both time and their experience of it (temporality), which reminds me of Sartre’s notion on time and the dissociation between chronos (clock time) and kairos (the experiencing of time). According to Sartre, ‘time is, above all, that which separates and the only solution for certain individuals is to freeze time, to stop the clock in order to foreclose the possibility of separation. The result is a present that is completely subsumed by the past and where the possibilities of the future are forever denied.’ Since temporality is a vital factor for the occurrence of separation, the denial of chronological time makes way for fantasies of interminability—on Bronzino’s canvas. The painting is typically mannerist in figura serpentina form, and the figures’ appearances as frozen objects in motion actually helps in portraying this rupture in experiencing time; the relationship between chronos and Kairos is destructed, hence leading to the pausing of time, along with the timeless concepts. Looking again, the concept of ‘freezing’—with the act of Chronus’s concealment of the embracing couple—pervades the painting in many ways. There is an icy coolness in the lascivious eyes and pose of Venus and Cupid, who have not usually been seen embracing in that manner. What also strikes me is that despite the passionate embrace, Bronzino seemed keen on keeping Venus and Cupid in the pale, stony color of cold marble, save for the ears and cheeks, which appear to be the only ‘warm’ spots in pink. Besides Venus’s frozen gaze and her complete dissociation from time and inexperience of temporality, the almost-dropped blue cloth reflects a protective measure--the freezing of time is meant to protect Venus and Cupid from the negative costs of pleasure and a kind of denial of the low qualities of love: Deception and Folly are at the right, along with Oblivion and a gruesome embodiment of Jealousy/Syphilis to the left. Folly’s stepping on the thorns may also signify the dangers of accompanying pain of such ‘love.’ The denial of time through freezing it is not only out of fear of separation, but it is out of Cupid and Venus’s fear of the other viles resulting from their transgressive love. Considering the fact that the painting was a gift from Cosimo de Medici to King Francis the 1st, and knowing the latter king’s love for puzzles and symbols, the motive behind Bronzino’s mystification is quite understandable…and perhaps the role of Time will remain unclear in Bronzino’s allegory. But whether the painting really illustrates this peculiar forbidden love’s denial/freezing of Time or not, there is an obvious break in—or lack of—their perception of it. And so, over a warm cup of tea, we continue the post-museum conversation about the loads of work art history still has ahead …until my brain can only respond by constructing a poem: From a spout among the ebony waves, I shake off a pair of tiny wings. A flutter fans its way out, Glossing away from the raven-dark depths, floating off, away from the confused mass, toward the glowing embers of a mysterious flicker …Like a moth to a flame I do not understand. Roula-Maria Dib Roula-Maria Dib is a university professor at the American University in Dubai where she teaches courses of English language and literature. She has published some poems, essays, and articles in magazines and journals such as Renaissance Hub, The Journal of Wyndham Lewis Studies, Agenda, Two Thirds North, and The Archive for Research in Archetypal Symbolism (ARAS). She is also currently finishing her PhD in Modernist Literature and Psychoanalysis from the University of Leeds in the UK. Her dissertation focuses on Modernist literature (namely the works of James Joyce, Hilda Doolittle, and W.B. Yeats) in light Carl Jung’s psychological theory of individuation, or spiritual transformation. The themes that pervade her work usually revolve around different aspects of human nature, art ekphrasis, surrealism, and the collective unconscious.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Support The Ekphrastic Review at Patreon. Click here for more info.
Scroll down for writers, archive by month, and categories
Writers
(use search box above) Sheikha A. Sherry Barker Abaldo Sarah Abbott Derek Adams Sudeep Adhikari Riham Adly Nazmi Ağıl Jocelyn Ajami Carol Alexander Dorothy Allan Meghan Rose Allen M.J. Arcangelini Mikki Aronoff Ruth Asch Tiffany Babb Deborah Bacharach Stacey Balkun Peter Balint Mary Jo Balistreri KB Ballentine Devon Balwit Ann Bar-Dov Daniel Barbare Carol Barbour Andy Barnett Danetta Barney Rick Barot Tom Barlow Mike Barrett Virginia Barrett Paul Barron Phillip Barron Tina Barry Amy Baskin Roderick Bates Alessandra Bava Ruth Bavetta B. Elizabeth Beck Gary Beck Roy Beckemeyer Gabriella Bedetti Sherri Bedingfield Jack Belck James Bell Shelley Benaroya Margaret Benbow Cathy Bennett F.J. Bergmann Karen G. Berry Abra Bertman Robert Bharda Emily Bilman Bonnie Bishop Shelly Blankman Mark Blaeuer Susan P. Blevins Sally Bliumis-Dunn Lavina Blossom Rose Mary Boehm Greta Bolger Alan Botsford Jan Bottiglieri Emily Bowles Judith Bowles Charles M. Boyer Joe Boyle Jennifer Bradpiece Bob Bradshaw Norah Brady Craig Brandis Ruth Brandt Catherine A. Brereton Tony Brewer Charles W. Brice Paul Brookes Heather Browne David C. Brydges Mark Budman Richard Buhr Susan Buis Elizabeth Burnside Mary Lou Buschi Danielle Nicole Byington Aron Canter Ashley Capes Barbara Carlton Sarah Carleton Jacalyn Carley Wendy Taylor Carlisle Michael Carman Rachel Carney D. Carpenter Fern G. Z. Carr Andres Castro Jeremy Casabella Alan Catlin Laura Chalar Daniela Chamorro Catherine Chandler Daniel Chapman Yuan Changming Jari Chevalier Lee Chilcote Jamie Christensen Roberto Christiano Kersten Christianson Tricia Marcella Cimera Molly Cimikoski Sarah Clayville DeWitt Clinton Alicia Cole SuzAnne C. Cole Patrick Cole Christie Collins William Conelly Geraldine Connolly Lisa Conquet Luigi Coppola Tiffany Corley Paolo Cornacchia Victoria Crawford Neil Creighton Paul Crompton Barbara Crooker Rebekah Curry Grace Curtis Tom Daley Tony Daly Tammy Daniel Judith Dancoff Mark Danowsky Christina Daub Jim Davis Jon Davis Margo Davis Deborah Davitt Thomas Day Robert L. Dean, Jr. Jasmin Deans Barry DeCarli Joanne Rocky Delaplaine Barry Dempster Deborah DeNicola Isabella DeSendi Steve Deutsch John Scott Dewey Angelee Deodhar Melinda Dewsbury James Diaz Roula-Maria Dib Anthony DiMatteo Brendan Dixon Sharon Dolin Catherine Ruffing Drotleff Carla Drysdale Merridawn Duckler Ted Duke Kendall Dunkelberg Sue Dymoke Bryan Edenfield Suzanne E. Edison Kurt Cole Eidsvig Neil Ellman Tara A. Elliott Michael Estabrook Lee Evans Keith Fallows Alexis Rhone Fancher Mike Farren Gene Fendt Ken Fermoyle Garth Ferrante Irene Fick Melanie Figg Alexa Findlay Bob Findysz Ariel Rainer Fintushel Paul Fisher Catherine Fletcher Ian Fletcher Kelly Fordon J.R. Forman Dan Franch Daniel Fraser Jan Freeman Eric Fretz Omer Friedlander Miriam Gampel Edward H. Garcia Anne Garwig Pavlina Gatikova Adam J. Gellings Michelle Geoga Karen George Michael Gessner Renee Gherity Stephen Gibson Jessica Gigot Mary Gilonne Mori Glaser Gary Glauber Laura Glenn Boris Glikman Shirley Glubka Gail Goepfert Samara Golabuk Amanda Gomez GTimothy Gordon Jack Grady Tanya Grae Grace Marie Grafton Lori Gravley Emily Reid Green Sonia Greenfield William Greenway Joann Grisetti Rebeca Ladrón de Guevara Laura Quinn Guidry Fred Guyette Deborah Guzzi Annest Gwilym Andrea L. Hackbarth Jennifer Hambrick Kim Hamilton Andrew Hanson Richard Hanson Summer Hardinge Michael Harmon Hilary Hauck Roxy Hearn Matthew Hefferin Kathleen Hellen Magdelyn Hammond Helwig Nicole Henares Michael Henry David Henson Judith Lee Herbert W.M. Herring Nancy Hewitt John Hicks Anne Higgins Sørina Higgins Norbert Hirschhorn Matthew Hittinger Ruth Hoberman Juleigh Howard-Hobson Steve Hosking Veronica Hosking Elizabeth Hoover Billy Howell-Sinnard Daniel Hudon David Huddle Antony Huen Melissa Huff A. J. Huffman Pat Snyder Hurley Liz Hutchinson Michele Hyatt-Blankman Nancy Iannucci Susan Ioannou Jessica Isaacs M.J.Iuppa Christine Jackson Michael Janairo Arya F. Jenkins Elizabeth Jennings Nancy Jentsch David Jibson Brandon D. Johnson Leah Johnson Catharine Jones Kitty Jospé Judy Kaber Gabe Kahan Jen Karetnick Crystal Condakes Karlberg Christopher T. Keaveney Collin Kelley Tina Kelley Penn Kemp Mary Kendall Diane Kendig Caesar Kent Olivia J. Kiers Siân Killingsworth Sarah Kilgallon Crad Kilodney Maureen Kingston Steve Klepetar Loretta Collins Klobah Elizabeth Knapp Tricia Knoll Kim Peter Kovac Norbert Kovacs Jean L. Kreiling Leonard Kress Sandhya Krishnakumar Jack Kristiansen Judy Kronenfeld Stuart A. Kurtz Tanmoy Das Lala Joe Lamport Susanna Lang W.F. Lantry Kyle Laws Hank Lawson Jenna Le John R. Lee Philip Lee Max Lemuz Ethan Leonard Joan Leotta Kat Lewis Terri Lewis Marjorie Lewis-Jones Annie Lighthart Alexander Limarev Carl Lindquist Zach Lindsey Peter Lingard David Ross Linklater Maria Lisella Christina Lloyd Ellaraine Lockie Virginia Lowe Gregory E. Lucas Gregory Luce Veronica Lupinacci Joseph Lisowski Kim Lozano Lorette C. Luzajic M. L. Lyons Ashley Mabbitt Joan MacIntosh Cyndi MacMillan Kate MacQueen Tamara Madison Marjorie Maddox Jordan Makant Stephane Mallarme Ariel S. Maloney Kim Mannix John C. Mannone Clint Margrave Liz Marlow Betsy Mars Jennifer Martelli Carolyn Martin Pam Martin Sheila Martin Joel Martyr Andrew Marvell dl mattila Dorian Maynard Tim Mayo Bernadette McBride Marilyn McCabe Sarah McCall Mary C. McCarthy Susan McCaslin Mary McCulley Paul McDonald Joshua McGarry Neill McKee Carol McMahon Lisa McMonagle Meryl McQueen Megan Denese Mealor Josh Medsker Ed Meek Rhonda Melanson Herman Melville Didi Menendez Todd Mercer Mary Meriam Jennifer Met Patrick G. Metoyer Andrew Miller David P. Miller Stacy Boe Miller Elaine Mintzer Ken Mitchell Mark J. Mitchell Rumi Morkin Elizabeth Morton Hallie Moore Mark A. Murphy Matthew Murrey Lylanne Musselman Kati Nagy S. Jagathsimhan Nair Lee Nash Jeff Nazzaro Heather M. Nelson Robbi Nester Gillian Nevers Emily Newman Sarah Nichols James B. Nicola Bruce W. Niedt Kim Patrice Nunez Heather Ober M. N. O'Brien Kerry O’Connor Frank O'Hara Susan Olding René Ostberg Pravat Kumar Padhy Laura Page Pattie Palmer-Baker Gregory Palmerino Christa Pandey Mary Panke Jimmy Pappas Dale Patterson Kathryn Paul Gail Peck James Penha Nancy Penrose Laurel Peterson Garrett Phelan Sharon Phillips Amy Phimister Diana Pinckney Daniel J. Pizappi bart plantenga Sylvia Plath Kenneth Pobo Rich Polanski Adam Pollak Melissa Reeser Poulin Rhonda C. Poynter Marcia J. Pradzinski Catherine Prescott Mirissa Price Anita S. Pulier Jessica Purdy Grant Quackenbush Philip Quinlan Ryan Racine David Radavich Rajani Radhakrishnan Simeon Ralph Mary Rees Adam Reger James Reidel Christian Reifsteck Amie E. Reilly D.D. Renforth Noah Renn J. Stephen Rhodes Adrienne Rich Susan Rich John Riley Vicki Roberts Denis Robillard Julia Rocchi Ralph La Rosa Charlie Rossiter Anca Rotar Jonathan Rowe William Ruleman Mary Kay Rummell Mary Harris Russell Sarah Russell Janet Ruth Janet St. John Lisa St. John Kelly R. Samuels Austin Sanchez-Moran Jennifer Sanders Christy Sheffield Sanford Sherod Santos Jo-Ella Sarich LeighAnna Schesser Peter Schireson Brad Schmidt William Schmidtkunz Tina Schumann Maddison Scott J.D. Scrimgeour Shloka Shankar Jake Sheff Maureen Sherbondy Beth Sherman Dave Shortt Neil Silberblatt Mark Silverberg Cora Siré Alifair Skebe Barnaby Smith Courtney O'Banion Smith m.j.smith Shadwell Smith Crystal Snoddon Renee Soasey Janice D. Soderling Kathleen Stancik Gregory Stapp Anthony Stechyson J.J. Steinfeld Michele Stepto Lisa Stice Kathleen Stone M. Stone Ryan Stone Nigel Stuart Lesley Strutt Linda Stryker Todd Sukany David Allen Sullivan Anne Swannell Marianne Szlyk Kim Cope Tait Mary Ellen Talley Charles Tarlton Holden Taylor Jo Taylor Jonathan Taylor Liza Nash Taylor Peter Taylor Alarie Tennille Lindsey Thäden Robert Thiessen Taunja Thomson J.C. Todd Peter Tolly Juanita Torrence-Thompson Sharon Tracey Rekha Valliappan Janine Pommy Vega Andrew Vinstra Yvonne Vinstra Margaret Wack Robert Walicki Sue Brannan Walker Alan Walowitz Robert Walton Noah Wareness Paul Waring Richard Waring Ryan Warren Bill Waters Mindy Watson David Watt Rhett Watts Tom Wayman Mercedes Webb-Pullman Rebecca Weigold Sheila Wellehan Tyson West Harley White Richard Wilbur Dan Wilcox T.E. Wilderson Martin Willitts Jr Jane Williams William Carlos Williams Ernest Williamson Morgan Grayce Willow Shannon Connor Winward Guinotte Wise Lee Woodman Christopher Woods Patrick Wright Robert Wynne William Butler Yeats Mantz Yorke Amy Young Mark Young Jonathan Yungkans Jeffrey Zable Abigail Ardelle Zammit Andrena Zawinski Shelby Zurcher Archives
April 2018
Our primary objective is to promote writing, art and artists today and through history. All works of art are used with permission of the creator or publisher, OR under public domain, OR under fair use. If any works have been used or credited incorrectly, please alert us so we can fix it.
|